Files
openssl/NOTES-C99.md
Richard Levitte 4a0d4a5c3a
Some checks failed
GitHub CI / check_update (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / check_docs (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / check-c99 (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / basic_gcc (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / basic_clang (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / linux-arm64 (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / freebsd-x86_64 (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / minimal (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / no-deprecated (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / no-shared-ubuntu (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / no-shared-macos (macos-13) (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / no-shared-macos (macos-14) (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / non-caching (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / address_ub_sanitizer (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / fuzz_tests (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / memory_sanitizer (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / threads_sanitizer (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / enable_non-default_options (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / full_featured (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / no-legacy (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / legacy (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / out-of-readonly-source-and-install-ubuntu (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / out-of-readonly-source-and-install-macos (macos-13) (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / out-of-readonly-source-and-install-macos (macos-14) (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / external-tests-misc (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / external-tests-oqs-provider (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / external-tests-pkcs11-provider (push) Has been cancelled
GitHub CI / external-tests-pyca (3.9) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-10) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-11) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-12) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-13) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-14) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / gcc (gcc-9) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-11) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-12) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-13) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-14) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-15) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-16) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-17) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-18) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-19) (push) Has been cancelled
Compiler Zoo CI / clang (clang-20) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:aarch64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-arm64-cross target:linux-aarch64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:alpha-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6.1-dev-alpha-cross target:linux-alpha-gcc]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:arm-linux-gnueabi fips:no libs:libc6-dev-armel-cross target:linux-armv4 tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:arm-linux-gnueabihf fips:no libs:libc6-dev-armhf-cross target:linux-armv4 tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:hppa-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-hppa-cross target:-static -O1 linux-generic32 tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:hppa-linux-gnu libs:libc6-dev-hppa-cross target:linux-generic32 tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:i386-pc-msdosdjgpp libs:libc-djgpp-dev libwatt-djgpp-dev djgpp-utils ppa:jwt27/djgpp-toolchain target:no-threads 386 DJGPP tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:m68k-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-m68k-cross target:-static -m68040 linux-latomic -Wno-stringop-overflow tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:m68k-linux-gnu libs:libc6-dev-m68k-cross target:-mcfv4e -mxgot linux-latomic -Wno-stringop-overflow no-quic tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:mips-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-mips-cross target:-static linux-mips32 tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:mips-linux-gnu libs:libc6-dev-mips-cross target:linux-mips32 tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:mips64-linux-gnuabi64 fips:no libs:libc6-dev-mips64-cross target:-static linux64-mips64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:mips64-linux-gnuabi64 libs:libc6-dev-mips64-cross target:linux64-mips64 tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:mipsel-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-mipsel-cross target:linux-mips32 tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:powerpc64le-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-ppc64el-cross target:linux-ppc64le]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:s390x-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-s390x-cross target:linux64-s390x]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:sh4-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-sh4-cross target:no-async linux-latomic tests:-test_includes -test_store -test_x509_store]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile / cross-compilation (map[arch:sparc64-linux-gnu libs:libc6-dev-sparc64-cross target:linux64-sparcv9 tests:none]) (push) Has been cancelled
Fuzz-checker CI / fuzz-checker (map[cc:afl-clang-fast config:enable-fuzz-afl no-module install:afl++ name:AFL]) (push) Has been cancelled
Fuzz-checker CI / fuzz-checker (map[cc:clang-18 config:enable-fuzz-libfuzzer enable-asan enable-ubsan -fno-sanitize=function -fsanitize-coverage=trace-cmp -DFUZZING_BUILD_MODE_UNSAFE_FOR_PRODUCTION extra:enable-fips enable-lms enable-ec_nistp_64_gcc_128 -fno-sanitize=al… (push) Has been cancelled
Fuzz-checker CI / fuzz-checker (map[cc:clang-18 config:enable-fuzz-libfuzzer enable-asan enable-ubsan -fno-sanitize=function install:libfuzzer-18-dev libs:--with-fuzzer-lib=/usr/lib/llvm-18/lib/libFuzzer.a --with-fuzzer-include=/usr/include/clang/18/include/fuzzer linke… (push) Has been cancelled
CIFuzz / Fuzzing (push) Has been cancelled
Perl-minimal-checker CI / perl-minimal-checker (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_inlineasm opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,zbb=true,zbkb=true,zknh=true,zksh=true target:-march=rv64gc_zbb_zbkb_zknh_zksh linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_v_zbb opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,v=true,vlen=128,zbb=true,zvbb=false,zvkb=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_v_zvkb_zvbc opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,v=true,vlen=128,zvbb=true,zvbc=true,zvkg=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_v_zvkg opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,v=true,vlen=128,zvkg=true,zvbb=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_v_zvkned opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,v=true,vlen=128,zvkned=true,zvbb=false,zvkb=false,zvkg=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_zba_zbb_zbc_zbs_zbkb_zbkc_zbkx_zknd_zkne_zknh_zksed_zksh_zkr_zkt_v_zvbb_zvbc_zvkb_zvkg_zvkned_zvknha_zvknhb_zvksed_zvksh opensslcapsname:riscvca… (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_zbb_zbc_zbkb_zknd_zkne opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,zbb=true,zbc=true,zbkb=true,zknd=true,zkne=true target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_zbc opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,zbc=true,zbb=false,zbkb=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Cross Compile for RISC-V Extensions / cross-compilation-riscv (map[arch:riscv64-linux-gnu fips:no libs:libc6-dev-riscv64-cross opensslcaps:rv64gc_zbc_zbb opensslcapsname:riscvcap qemucpu:rv64,zbc=true,zbb=true,zbkb=false target:linux64-riscv64]) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (enable-trace enable-fips) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-cmp) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-cms) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-default-thread-pool) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-dgram) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-dh) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-dtls) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-ec) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-ecx) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-http) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-legacy) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-ml-dsa) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-ml-kem) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-quic) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-sm2) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-sock) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-stdio) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-thread-pool) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-threads) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-tls) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-tls1_2) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-tls1_3) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker CI / run-checker (no-ui) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (enable-asan enable-ubsan no-shared no-asm -DOPENSSL_SMALL_FOOTPRINT -fno-sanitize=function) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (enable-pie) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (enable-ubsan no-asm -DOPENSSL_SMALL_FOOTPRINT -fno-sanitize=function) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (enable-weak-ssl-ciphers) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (enable-zlib) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-dso) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-dynamic-engine) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-ec2m enable-fips) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-engine no-shared) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-err) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-filenames) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-integrity-only-ciphers) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-module) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-ocsp) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-pinshared) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-srp) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-srtp) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / run-checker (no-ts) (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / jitter (push) Has been cancelled
Run-checker merge / threads_sanitizer_atomic_fallback (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / shared (map[arch:amd64 config:enable-lms enable-fips no-thread-pool no-quic os:windows-2025 vcvars:C:\Program Files\Microsoft Visual Studio\2022\Enterprise\VC\Auxiliary\Build\vcvars64.bat]) (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / shared (map[arch:amd64 config:enable-lms enable-fips os:windows-2022 vcvars:C:\Program Files\Microsoft Visual Studio\2022\Enterprise\VC\Auxiliary\Build\vcvars64.bat]) (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / shared (map[arch:x86 config:--strict-warnings no-fips enable-lms os:windows-2022 vcvars:C:\Program Files\Microsoft Visual Studio\2022\Enterprise\VC\Auxiliary\Build\vcvars32.bat]) (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / plain (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / minimal (push) Has been cancelled
Windows GitHub CI / cygwin (windows-2022, map[arch:win64 config:-DCMAKE_C_COMPILER=gcc --strict-warnings enable-demos no-fips]) (push) Has been cancelled
Add unsupported features in NOTES-C99.md: complex.h and variable length array
Resolves: https://github.com/openssl/openssl/issues/28598

Reviewed-by: Neil Horman <nhorman@openssl.org>
Reviewed-by: Shane Lontis <shane.lontis@oracle.com>
Reviewed-by: Tim Hudson <tjh@openssl.org>
Reviewed-by: Tom Cosgrove <tom.cosgrove@arm.com>
(Merged from https://github.com/openssl/openssl/pull/28602)
2025-09-23 10:36:15 +02:00

1.6 KiB

Notes on C-99

This file contains a list of C-99 features we don't allow for OpenSSL. Starting with 3.6 OpenSSL project is going to gradually adopt C-99 features. The plan is to bring those features in small steps. Either with new code where particular C-99 construct makes sense (think of designated initializers), or when refactoring existing code and using C-99 language feature improves readability/maintainability of the code. C-99 seems to be implemented by major compilers (clang, gcc, msvc), therefore we can opt for permissive policy to adopt C-99 standard. This approach means OpenSSL project accepts all C-99 features except those explicitly listed here. The list here is going to be updated by features we either

  • find not useful (or not a good match) for OpenSSL

  • the feature is not implemented by some non-mainstream compiler which we need to keep supported for benefit of OpenSSL users

The list of C-99 features we don't support in OpenSSL project follows:

  • do not use // for comments, stick to /* ... */

  • do not use <complex.h>. MSVC doesn't quite implement it to standard.

  • do not use variable length arrays, i.e. arrays where the size is determined by another variable. MSVC doesn't implement it at all. For clarity, this is an example of such an array:

    int fun(size_t n)
    {
        char s[n]; /* variable size array */
        ...